On November 20, 2026, the Supreme Court of Canada released its decision in R. v. Bilinski, 2026 SCC 40. In a 7-2 ruling, the Court upheld an order for a new trial after finding that the trial judge failed to properly instruct the jury on the meaning of communicated consent in a sexual assault case involving the removal of a condom during intercourse.
Writing for the majority, Justice Martin emphasized that consent must be communicated through words or conduct, and that juries must understand this requirement when assessing the accused’s state of mind. The decision was released on the same day as the related case R. v. Degale, 2026 SCC 39, which addressed similar issues of mens rea and consent.
If you are facing sexual assault charges in Mississauga, Brampton, or anywhere in the Greater Toronto Area, accurate jury instructions and a strong defence strategy can make a critical difference. Call our office at 905-755-0104 or use the booking link at the top of this page to arrange a consultation.
The Facts
The complainant invited her former boyfriend to her home. Before he arrived, she texted him that he would need to wear a condom if they engaged in sexual activity. During intercourse, the accused removed the condom and ejaculated inside her. He was charged with sexual assault.
At the jury trial in Alberta, the accused did not raise the defence of honest but mistaken belief in communicated consent. The central issues included whether the complainant had consented to sexual intercourse without a condom and the credibility and reliability of her evidence. The jury acquitted the accused. The Alberta Court of Appeal ordered a new trial, and the accused appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada.
The Supreme Court’s Decision
The majority dismissed the appeal and confirmed the order for a new trial. Key points include:
- Consent in sexual assault cases must be communicated by words or conduct. An accused cannot simply assume consent.
- Trial judges must adequately explain this concept to juries when they consider the accused’s state of mind (mens rea). Inadequate instructions create a real risk that a jury could acquit based on an assumption or belief that the complainant was consenting, which the law does not permit.
- Trial judges are not required to instruct juries that, if they find the complainant did not consent, they should have “little difficulty” finding that the accused knew of, was wilfully blind to, or was reckless about the lack of consent. Such an instruction can improperly interfere with the jury’s independent assessment of whether the Crown has proven the mental element beyond a reasonable doubt. Judges may give this type of instruction in appropriate cases.
- The Crown must always prove the accused’s state of mind beyond a reasonable doubt, even when the defence of honest but mistaken belief in communicated consent is not raised.
Justices Côté and Rowe dissented and would have restored the acquittal.
What This Means for Sexual Assault Cases in Ontario
This decision is highly relevant for anyone charged with sexual assault, particularly in cases involving alleged non-consensual condom removal (“stealthing”) or disputes about the scope of consent. It reinforces that:
- Consent must be affirmative and communicated.
- Jury instructions on the distinction between the physical element (actus reus) and the mental element (mens rea) of sexual assault must be clear and accurate.
- Defence counsel must carefully scrutinize proposed jury instructions and, where appropriate, object to incomplete or potentially misleading charges to the jury.
The ruling provides important guidance on how courts should approach these issues while protecting the accused’s right to a fair trial and the requirement of proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
Practical Implications for Defence Counsel
In sexual assault prosecutions, especially those proceeding before a jury, early attention to the following is essential:
- Review of disclosure for any evidence of prior communication about the scope of sexual activity (texts, messages, or statements).
- Strategic decisions about whether to raise an honest but mistaken belief in communicated consent defence.
- Careful drafting or objecting to jury instructions on communicated consent and mens rea.
- Consideration of related authorities, including the same-day decision in R. v. Degale, 2026 SCC 39.
Aswani K. Datt has extensive experience defending sexual assault and related charges in both the Ontario Court of Justice and the Superior Court of Justice throughout Peel Region and the GTA. Thorough preparation of jury instructions, evidentiary motions, and cross-examination strategy is critical in these cases.
Conclusion
R. v. Bilinski, 2026 SCC 40 clarifies the obligations of trial judges when instructing juries on communicated consent in sexual assault cases. It underscores that consent must be actively communicated and that juries must be properly guided on this principle when assessing the accused’s state of mind.
If you or a loved one is facing sexual assault charges, early and experienced legal representation can make a significant difference.
Call 905-755-0104 now to speak with Aswani K. Datt, or click the link at the top of this page to book a consultation for available times.
You do not have to face these charges alone. Get experienced criminal defence representation today.
